Did you know that fall is 40-45% of Americans favorite season? There’s a lot of reasons to love this time of year, but many love the fall leaves. However, I don’t think any of these people are the ones who clean their homes gutters. Thankfully, gutter guards exist, but with so many brands how do you pick? Well we scoured the web and for all the top gutter guard reviews to find you the top 5 gutter guard options for your home and budget.
This review covered different top brands, different type of gutter guard products, and customer feedback on how well the products performed. Let’s dive in and find the best gutter guard solution for your home.
Gutter Guard Reviews
Raptor Gutter Guard – Amazon Choice
Raptor Gutter Guards provides contractor-grade stainless steel and aluminum micro-mesh gutter guards, each style is available in silver, black, and white, and the available 5 in. or 6 in. width fits most gutters. A standard gutter guard kit is 48 ft. Raptor Gutter Guard ensures easy installation with slide-in gutter guards, self-tapping screws, and easy-to-follow instructions.
The Raptor Gutter Guard Amazon Choice products has 4.5 star rating with over 5,600 positive gutter guard reviews. Starting at $124.99 this product is more expensive than other gutter options, but Gutter Raptor has more affordable models too. Still, the micro-mesh model is a superior for keeping out debris while letting water through, and it competitively priced for that quality.
The quality, customer rating, and fast shipment all factor into why Raptor Gutter Guards are an Amazon Choice product.
- Top Product: Raptor Gutter Guard 48 ft. Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Contractor-Grade Standard Gutter Guard
- Additional Products: Exterior Light Clips, Gutter Guard Brush, Telescopic Brush Pole, and Perforated Rainwater Diverter.
- Top Gutter Guard Review: “Cleaning gutters is the worst. So I installed cheap rolls of plastic mesh. It was very difficult to install and did almost nothing. Needles, roof grit and worst of all, maple “helicopter seeds” built up even faster than before as they got in but couldn’t get out! After reviewing lots of designs and options this stainless steel micromesh seemed the most sensible option. I’ve installed nearly 300 ft of it. VERY easy to install, just slide it under the shingles, then three self tapping sheet metal screws. They even include a magnetic bit so you can do it all with one hand. There’s a bit of cutting around corners, and no, you cannot cut the aluminum rails with tin snips – I used a grinder with a cutting blade. Overall these look great and work great. Have been through at least two big rain storms. No overflow at all and nothing gets through other than water. Everything else blows away as there is nothing for it to catch on. I can’t believe I almost paid someone $25 a linear foot to install these! Less than $3 per ft, and done in a few hours.” – Amazon Review.
- Price: $124.99 for 5 in., $149.99 for 6 in. Try a Sample Pack for $8.90.
- Where to Buy: Amazon
A-M Gutter Guard – Amazon Best Seller
This next top-rated gutter guard is also from Amazon and is actually the Amazon Best Seller for gutter guards. This is another high-grade gutter guard, plus it comes with a lifetime “no rust” warranty. The installation seems more involved than Amazon Choice Raptor Gutter Guards, but customers still positively report back with easy installation.
A-M utilizes a “bubbled filtration system” to sift out any debris that comes along with rain. It is also specifically designed for hidden hangers, but is compatible with all types of gutters, including K-style. These gutters also won’t damage your roof during installation or use.
- Top Product: A-M Gutter Guard 5 in. Aluminum with Mill Finish
- Additional Products: Gutter Hangers and Zip Screws.
- Top Gutter Guard Review: “*4 Year Update at end* I am a 60 y/o woman and I just installed 50′ of these A-M 6″ gutter guards on my 5.5” gutters (with no help from anyone), and the whole job took me about 3-4 hours. They were a perfect fit, although I had to bend the back of them in some places in order for them to seat properly (due to my gutters not being even).”…”Properly installed, I can’t see how leaves could possibly enter the gutters,”… “*Update: It’s Dec. 2023 and I stand by everything I said about these leaf guards – even bumped my rating up a notch to 5 stars. We’ve had zero problems with leaves or anything else clogging our gutters. They’ve literally been maintenance free. I do have to clean leaves off of the top of them at the corners twice a year, but that has nothing to do with the guards. They have held up just fine & haven’t rusted or had any other issues. Great product.”
- Price: $84.99 for 50 ft., but available in a variety of sizes from 11.5 ft. to 200 ft.
- Where to Buy: Amazon
Gutterglove
Gutterglove Gutter Guards, a popular hardware store brand. You can easily find Gutterglove at The Home Depot. While the Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh model is one of their most popular, Gutterglove provides a variety of gutter guards to fit all budgets.
We looked for gutter guard reviews that discussed the installation and performance. We are happy to report back that many customers find this gutter guard easy to install and required no maintenance after a full season aside from clearing off the tops of the guard.
- Top Product: Gutterglove 4 ft. L X 5 in. W Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard
- Additional Products: Gutter Brush.
- Top Gutter Guard Review: “Ive waited a season to write this review, to see how well this product worked at keeping leaves and debris out of my gutters. Our house is surrounded by trees and clogged gutters have been the norm, but with the addition of these guards i am happy to report they did an amazing job! I did not have to call the gutter cleaning service this year. The leaves just blew off the roof and the gutters remained clean and flowing.”
- Price: $186.98
- Where to Buy: The Home Depot
Amerimax
We have seen a lot of high-quality and built-to last gutter guards. However, they’ve each had a considerable price tag. Some of us are on a budget, or maybe we’re renting and we don’t want to over-invest in our gutter guards. Amerimax Snap-In Gutter Guards are a great option for those who need an affordable and temporary option.
Amerimax Snap-In Gutter Guards are also easy to install. Like the name says, you snap them in and you are done. They also offer a variety of useful gutter guard products, such as downspout covers and flexible spouts for diverting rainwater.
- Top Product: Amerimax 6 in. W X 36 in. L White PVC Snap-in Filter 1-Pack
- Additional Products: Downspout Covers, Flexible Spouts, Splash Block, Gutter Hangers. View Amerimax products at ACE Hardware.
- Top Gutter Guard Review: “Works very well. Easy to install.” – ACE Hardware Review
- Price: Products range on average from $2.50 to $20.
- Where to Buy: The Home Depot, ACE Hardware.
GutterFoam
GutterFoam is another great affordable gutter guard product for customers looking for an affordable option. Gutter foam slides in under the lip of your gutter. It blocks debris and the foam provides some filtration for water to flow and run through the gutter.
Similar to Amerimax, GutterFoam offers a variety of gutter guard products. These include downspout filters, and a variety of GutterFoam for different styles of gutters.
- Top Product: GutterFoam Plastic Filter
- Additional Products: Plastic Downspout Filters, various GutterFoam Filters. View GutterFoam products at The Home Depot.
- Top Gutter Guard Review: “GutterFoam was easy to install in less than an hour on a ranch home. We’ve been having heavy rains today and there are no overflows anywhere on the gutters. Before the rains came , leaves just blew right off. None getting stuck anywhere. This is a great product and money well spent. Beats the metal toppers hands down! Also they cannot be seen from the ground.” – Home Depot Review
- Price: Products can range from $5 to $130+.
- Where to Buy: The Home Depot
TIA’s Favorite Gutter Guard
When comparing gutter guards we kept two main things in mind: price and quality.
Whether you were looking for a system to last or to just through a season, we wanted to make sure you didn’t overpay and that the system would last. With this in mind we came to two winners.
- Raptor Gutter Guard: Best Gutter Guards for Homeowners
- Amerimax: Best Gutter Guards for Budgets & Renters
Raptor Gutter Guards is our best all around pick because after reading all the gutter guard reviews we felt this brand offered the best quality at the best price. It’s also easy to install so you can avoid the added expense of installation. Another thing that stood out in the 5,000+ gutter guard reviews was how well this product held up overtime.
Amerimax was our favorite gutter guard system for those on a budget or in temporary living situations. All the gutter guard reviews remarked how easy this system was to use, plus we loved the variety of offers. In addition to be effective and easy to install, it’s also easy to take down, making it a renter-friendly product.
We’d love to hear your own personal gutter guard reviews. Tell us which system you use or have used and why you love it or hate it.
