What are your favorite phillips power bits?

AndrullMember since Apr 2015

Nope. I would guess theese are first gen. At least they were bought half a year ago, and probably been at the shop for some time.

So nothing new, and I have seen you guys have pretty much agreed on it beeing pretty bad. Just didn’t think it was this bad, and that you had been to rough/exagerrated it a little. I actually though the bits was okay. Untill now. 😛

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

The new ones have red on the shank, similar to how Dewalt uses yellow. But yeah, the new ones are less than three months old(In the US, not sure about Norway) so you’re definitely right in your assumption 🙂

 

It’s really hard to trust Milwaukee bits after the first shockwave, there are a lot of things to complain about but the softness of the steel really makes you question any bits coming out of that factory. The general consensus on Milwaukee’s pliers are along the same lines but not as extreme.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

[External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]

The WIha look sexy with my red husky m12 bag.

I love these bits that fit very nicely in the screw, real hard to strip with them they just grab everything.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

The more bits I use the more I find that Dewalt, Bosch and other big name, easy to find brands are just serviceable bits. The Europeans and even some high quality Taiwan bits are on a whole different level of quality and live a longer life…though they are more expensive. I’m sure the US-made bits are also very good but they’re even more expensive.

 

Though in the case of these: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-contractor-insert-bit-2-30-piece-p/72522.htmcurrently they’re actually cheaper than the Dewalt Maxfit and both are impact rated. Though Wiha has this guy which is significantly more expensive: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-terminator-impact-bit-2-x-29mm-2pk-p/76802.htm (If you plan on ordering some to try out, shipping to me for something like this plus some add-ons is about $5-6, free shipping at $50)

 

I’m currently waiting on my Swiss bits to show up…but these are expensive as hell.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

BMack37 wrote:

The more bits I use the more I find that Dewalt, Bosch and other big name, easy to find brands are just serviceable bits. The Europeans and even some high quality Taiwan bits are on a whole different level of quality and live a longer life…though they are more expensive. I’m sure the US-made bits are also very good but they’re even more expensive.

Though in the case of these: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-contractor-insert-bit-2-30-piece-p/72522.htmcurrently they’re actually cheaper than the Dewalt Maxfit and both are impact rated. Though Wiha has this guy which is significantly more expensive: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-terminator-impact-bit-2-x-29mm-2pk-p/76802.htm (If you plan on ordering some to try out, shipping to me for something like this plus some add-ons is about $5-6, free shipping at $50)

I’m currently waiting on my Swiss bits to show up…but these are expensive as hell.

The ones I scored at HD were the terminator ones, I love them things.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

BMack37 wrote:

The more bits I use the more I find that Dewalt, Bosch and other big name, easy to find brands are just serviceable bits. The Europeans and even some high quality Taiwan bits are on a whole different level of quality and live a longer life…though they are more expensive. I’m sure the US-made bits are also very good but they’re even more expensive.

 

Though in the case of these: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-contractor-insert-bit-2-30-piece-p/72522.htmcurrently they’re actually cheaper than the Dewalt Maxfit and both are impact rated. Though Wiha has this guy which is significantly more expensive: http://www.kctoolco.com/wiha-phillips-terminator-impact-bit-2-x-29mm-2pk-p/76802.htm (If you plan on ordering some to try out, shipping to me for something like this plus some add-ons is about $5-6, free shipping at $50)

 

I’m currently waiting on my Swiss bits to show up…but these are expensive as hell.

PB Swiss?  Yeah dude they are pricey.    I have some non terminator Wiha bits that are pretty good. The Terminators I wanna get some time. I have several Dewalt FlexTorq kits I like even thou they are kinda soft tipped. My Bosch ones i gave to my kids for their kit.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Fazzman wrote:

PB Swiss? Yeah dude they are pricey. I have some non terminator Wiha bits that are pretty good. The Terminators I wanna get some time. I have several Dewalt FlexTorq kits I like even thou they are kinda soft tipped. My Bosch ones i gave to my kids for their kit.

I have the flex torq and the max fit and I like the max fit 100 times better

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

You can actually see the quality difference through the packaging. I previously avoided Dewalt bits because I saw the poor quality of the machining on the Flex Torq. I’m starting to like Felo quite a bit right now, not just their bits…all of the items I have bought from Felo is very high quality. Their larger bits are a bit pricey though. 

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

Felo makes some really nice stuff,their screwdrivers are awesome.  I have some Swiss made precision tools,they are so nice and smooth to use.

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

Fazzman wrote:

Felo makes some really nice stuff,their screwdrivers are awesome.  I have some Swiss made precision tools,they are so nice and smooth to use.

 

I bought one of the Felo screwdrivers, think I’m going to buy the rest of the set this month…they’re fantastic. I don’t know why more people don’t talk about Felo, everyone is caught up on Wera and Wiha.

 

I might have to look at those PB Swiss precision, I like the look of the handles. I’ve been using a Stanley set buy they’re starting to get worn. Also been looking at the Wiha set in the canvas roll.

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

I have 2 sets of Wiha precision screwdrivers,I use them pretty often actually for changing batteries in kids toys to tightening up our glasses and what not. I swapped alot of my screwdriver type tools to Wiha and Wera because they are easy to get from industrial suppliers that come to the shop, like Western tool and such. Also they are usually pretty good priced on Amazon. I like my Wera kraftforms too.

comp56Member since Sep 2014

only use philips for drywall everything else is Robertson bits…..

 

[External image (www.leevalley.com), not copied]

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Picked up a shockwave 2 kit at HD for cheap to give it a try.

They aren’t too bad, big improvement from the gen 1. Driving screws they grip well, I wasn’t using an imply but a drill. I didn’t strip anything driving in. They struggled on removing the screws though. Using the same drill they didn’t want to bite into the screw as well as driving them. I had a little bit of stripping the head and some shavings, the bits are harder than the previous ones though.

Overall they aren’t bad, not as nice as them wiha terminators though, sadly my bar for bits is a lot higher now.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

If they’re are machined like the old ones, that problem may be that they are JIS and not phillips. JIS is a little loose in a phillips head screw so it cams out under high torque.

 

 

…and Comp, I wish everything I dealt with every day was Robertsons, I hate phillips head.

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

Finally bit the bullet and bought some of the Gen II Milwaukee bits…not very happy with them again. First, all five bits are warped/bent(not going to be an issue on 1″ bits), machining/quality control is not very good. Metal still seems softer than the Japanese/Taiwan/German/Czech bits.

 

Here’s a pic of the quality control, notice the cut of the heads are different depths and finish in different spots. Some of these fit in screws better than others.

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

 

Here’s a comparison of the head difference in the first gen versus the second gen:

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

I picked up a kit and they kind of suck, they suck less than the first gen but still not a fan of them.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

Bought the Kobalt bit. It’s not impact rated but this is a really nice bit, my initial impression of it in-store was pretty high…looked to be machined well, it is. Best fitment of any Chinese bit I’ve tried, closest comparison is the Dewalt Maxfit bits. No comment to durability yet but the metal sure seems more dense than the other Chinese bits. We’ll see…

 

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

My PB Swiss bits FINALLY came in:

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Oooooo ahhhhhhhh

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

redmedMember since Dec 2014

BMack37 wrote:

Bought the Kobalt bit. It’s not impact rated but this is a really nice bit, my initial impression of it in-store was pretty high…looked to be machined well, it is. Best fitment of any Chinese bit I’ve tried, closest comparison is the Dewalt Maxfit bits. No comment to durability yet but the metal sure seems more dense than the other Chinese bits. We’ll see…

 

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]

I have been impressed with the Kobalt’s.

KnarlyCarlMember since Jan 2016

BMack37 wrote:

I picked up a Dewalt MaxFit and ordered Blue Point bits to add to the test group. I will post my results but it will take a looong time, so that’s why this is my first time mentioning it…these results will be like a year from now. I will post fit and comparison photos by early next week when all the bits are in. The only ones I think I’m missing is Apex, Zephyr and PB Swiss but the shipping rates are killing me. Maybe by the end of the sampling I will pick some of those up, seems like PB Swiss is going to have to come from Japan. Apex and Zephyr is a minimum $50 order and $10+ shipping. I believe I have Zephyr covered with the Blue Point bits but I’ll have to do some more research to confirm.

i’d like to add Makita gold bits to the group but I need a 3-4 inch bit and their 3.5″ bit is a double-sided phillips and I’ve never been a fan of double sided, they tend to wobble.

Awesome really looking forward to reading the results of yourself and others as they come in.

Thanks for the in depth analysis of all these bits everyone!

Probably 80% of my work I use 1/4″ hex nut driver, then 5/16″ nut driver, and maybe 3/8″ and torx here and there.

Been looking at the Milwaukee shockwave bits (being the Milwaukee nut that I am) but I’m not going to now. Really want to check out the Wera bits tho for sure.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

I definitely recommend staying away from the Shockwaves, at HD I’d tell you to buy the Dewalt Maxfit if you’re buying the bulk 1″ bits and if you’re buying for longevity, buy Makita(just my opinion).

 

I ordered a couple more bit brands, Toptul(Taiwan) and Vermont America Deckster(USA), both have anti-cam out ribs. Vermont America also offers an “Ice bit” which is claimed to be “Super toughened” that I may add, depending on the quality of the Deckster bits. I was under the impression that Vermont America moved all their production overseas when they were acquired by Bosch and heard the quality went downhill so I had avoided buying them earlier.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Second what Bmack said grab the Dewalt Max fits, really nice bits and you can get a kit around 13 bucks

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

DR99Member since Nov 2012

BMack37 wrote:

If they’re are machined like the old ones, that problem may be that they are JIS and not phillips. JIS is a little loose in a phillips head screw so it cams out under high torque.

 

 

…and Comp, I wish everything I dealt with every day was Robertsons, I hate phillips head.

The troubles of being American. Finally in the past few years better drive styles have taken off. I see more options at big box stores than ever. You still see a crap load of Phillips bits though

comp56Member since Sep 2014

yup pretty much only use robertson #2 in fact if the Kreg screws were not #2 robertson probably wouldn’t be using them either….

I do have to mention i like using the round shank bits in case I’m up against finished wood so it doesn’t mark as much

 

[External image (www.blattsbargains.com), not copied]

jeffmcmillanMember since Jun 2015

The phillips drive itself doesn’t cause problems nearly as much as the implementation.  A lot of screws either try to get by with a smaller phillips size than they should, or don’t make the drive head deep enough.

 

Have you broken any of the bits yet BMack?  I broke a maxfit bit in a drywall screw last week (first time I’ve seen anything fail before a drywall screw).  Pissed me off so much I had to take a walk back to get my own impact and bits before I hammered the screw the rest of the way with the guy’s impact.  I know they’re not impact rated but my drill can snap the head of a drywall screw.

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

jeffmcmillan wrote:

The phillips drive itself doesn’t cause problems nearly as much as the implementation.  A lot of screws either try to get by with a smaller phillips size than they should, or don’t make the drive head deep enough.

 

Have you broken any of the bits yet BMack?  I broke a maxfit bit in a drywall screw last week (first time I’ve seen anything fail before a drywall screw).  Pissed me off so much I had to take a walk back to get my own impact and bits before I hammered the screw the rest of the way with the guy’s impact.  I know they’re not impact rated but my drill can snap the head of a drywall screw.

 

I have not but I haven’t been able to do any projects that were really stressful, nothing with the Impact driver. I’ve been dealing with some lingering injuries so none of those projects are getting done. At work I use the bits everyday so I can see the wear on just driving with a light clutch setting mostly…you can see wear from general usage in this way but no strength testing, that comes with the homeowner stuff for me. I was also planning on doing some testing by just driving a bunch of screws into a piece of wood but the injuries are killing me. 

 

The Maxfits are impact rated 🙂

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

BMack37 wrote:

I have not but I haven’t been able to do any projects that were really stressful, nothing with the Impact driver. I’ve been dealing with some lingering injuries so none of those projects are getting done. At work I use the bits everyday so I can see the wear on just driving with a light clutch setting mostly…you can see wear from general usage in this way but no strength testing, that comes with the homeowner stuff for me. I was also planning on doing some testing by just driving a bunch of screws into a piece of wood but the injuries are killing me.

The Maxfits are impact rated 🙂

Just bought a max fit t25 Torx and #2 Philips in 6″ length for my kreg jig.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

jimboslice wrote:

Just bought a max fit t25 Torx and #2 Philips in 6″ length for my kreg jig.

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

They’re really good value, the 6″ Maxfit is as much as the 3.5″ Makita gold. The Makita gold is two sided but it only works if you wear out the tip, if you break the bit it’s not reusable.

jeffmcmillanMember since Jun 2015

BMack37 wrote:

I have not but I haven’t been able to do any projects that were really stressful, nothing with the Impact driver. I’ve been dealing with some lingering injuries so none of those projects are getting done. At work I use the bits everyday so I can see the wear on just driving with a light clutch setting mostly…you can see wear from general usage in this way but no strength testing, that comes with the homeowner stuff for me. I was also planning on doing some testing by just driving a bunch of screws into a piece of wood but the injuries are killing me. 

 

The Maxfits are impact rated 🙂

 

Sorry to hear that.  I hope everything finishes healing up soon.

 

I’m surprised to hear maxfit are impact rated.  Just recall flextorque being impact rated, and the maxfit felt more like non impact rated bits.

redmedMember since Dec 2014

Jasonc wrote:

The troubles of being American. Finally in the past few years better drive styles have taken off. I see more options at big box stores than ever. You still see a crap load of Phillips bits though

I agree.  I want to go with Robertson drive screws but have a large stash of Phillips.  When looking to start my Roberson stash I found almost all Phillips stuff.  Had to search to find Robertson screws then when I did find them they where at least twice the cost. 

 

For now I have given up my quest for Robertson stuff as being impractical and focused on finding quality Phillips bits and screwdrivers.

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

jeffmcmillan wrote:

Sorry to hear that.  I hope everything finishes healing up soon.

 

I’m surprised to hear maxfit are impact rated.  Just recall flextorque being impact rated, and the maxfit felt more like non impact rated bits.

 

Thanks Jeff 🙂

 

Yeah, I agree, they’re more substantial feeling than most impact bits but the little collar on it is enough. The Flextorque is a pretty crappy bit, in my opinion…you can even see it through the packaging. My initial impression back before this thread started was that Dewalt bits were about as good as Milwaukee…then Jimbo and another member who’s name slips my mind at the moment mentioned the Maxfit and they were right. The difference in QC between Flextorque and Maxfit looks like it’s coming from two different companies.

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

redmed wrote:

I agree.  I want to go with Robertson drive screws but have a large stash of Phillips.  When looking to start my Roberson stash I found almost all Phillips stuff.  Had to search to find Robertson screws then when I did find them they where at least twice the cost. 

 

For now I have given up my quest for Robertson stuff as being impractical and focused on finding quality Phillips bits and screwdrivers.

 

Same here, that’s kind of the whole point of this thread haha. We’re pretty much stuck with phillips, which sucks, so we need good bits to make up for phillips’ shortcomings. I wish everything was Robertson or torx, but I deal with mostly phillips and JIS. At least we’re getting close to eliminating the need for slotted.

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

In the UK we can’t get the max fit bits which is a shame as I would like to try them but I’m using the fleq torque Philips bit daily and I like the fit but I agree the other head types aren’t the best

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

I just bought a maxfit set at HD over the holidays, they are nice bits. The quality of them is apparent compared to FlexTorqs of which I have 2 sets. The Maxfit set that was under $9 has a pretty decent bit selection.  No nutsetters like the FlexTorq kits i have bit thats not a biggie The Magnet is also a bit different but seems to be pretty strong. The Maxfits I have chillin with my Bosch 12v stuff currently as it fits inside the bag with 2 tools pretty easily.

 

ive had pretty good luck with Dewalt bits for what I do around the house,at work I like using my wiha and Wera bits.

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

Yeah they look better , would you say they last longer and how does the ph2 bits fit compared to the flex torque ?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

I dunno if they last longer quite yet,I never had any real issues with the flextorq except for the fit on some fasteners.,the maxfit was under $9 for the holidays.the fitment does seem better at least on the Phillips. We use alot of torx and hex bits at the shop doing assembly. The FlexTorq locking bit holder is pretty boss,best bit holder ive ever used.

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

Ok well if I find any with decent postage from the USA I will buy some but I will show you how much they are for me at the minute on eBay [External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

Yeah thats a nice kit. My FlexTorq kits were that price or more when I got mine.

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

So would you say it’s worth the money and one more thing do the max fits rust if they get wet as the old style shock waves do ?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FazzmanMember since Apr 2014

Well Ive only had the maxfits for a short time,several weeks at most so Rust i dont know,but I have some older Apex branded ones that have a bit of rust on them. a little WD-40 or something if they get wet wont hurt 🙂  Id say they are worth the money. The small kit of maxfits i have are worth everybit of the $9 I paid so far,I like having a good variety of bits.

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

That’s good to hear thanks

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Flex torq are only marginally better than shockwaves, I use max fits like ta my religion…

In another note back to the wera conversation here’s some Torx keys I got a week or so ago

[External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]

[External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]

[External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

They look good bits

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

Not bits lol

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

Craig, I’d love to help you out with getting some but last time I checked shipping to the UK was like $40, insane. About 6 years ago that would have cost more like $12 🙁

Craigh9916Member since Oct 2015

BMack37 wrote:

Craig, I’d love to help you out with getting some but last time I checked shipping to the UK was like $40, insane. About 6 years ago that would have cost more like $12 🙁

thanks but it’s ok on eBay the postage is about $18 or something so a set will cost me about £35 delivered ! I seem to have loads of impact bits but always want more lol

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BMack37Member since Sep 2015

Craigh9916 wrote:

thanks but it’s ok on eBay the postage is about $18 or something so a set will cost me about £35 delivered ! I seem to have loads of impact bits but always want more lol

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

How much would a set of Wiha, Wera, PB Swiss or Felo cost you? I know prices are higher in the UK but if it’s anywhere close to the cost of the Dewalt set, I’d consider those. The big thing about that set that makes us like it so much is the value, it’s cheap for a lot of quality bits…but it’s not German/Swiss/Czech quality. I just don’t want you paying high-end money for those bits.

 

…though the screw holder might be worth it anyway because I don’t think you can’t really get it anywhere else.

You are the influencer. Post it to 4.4 million followers.

Hit record. We’ll handle the rest.

Upload your review