Archived from the Tools In Action forum (Accessories). This thread is read-only.
I’ve been trying to find some bits I really liked, so far the favorite is the Bosch ribbed for her pleasure bits. I have several bits I’m going to test incoming, in all the bits I either already have used of will use include: Bosch, Milwaukee(1st gen), Irwin, Makita(though not extensive use), Wiha(incoming), Wera(3 different incoming), Felo(incoming). I haven’t used Dewalt, Apex or Zephyr but I’ve heard good things about all three. I just want a good resource of what everyone’s favorite bits are, where you can find them and why they’re your preferred bit. There’s a huge selection so please be specific, I’m sure we can all learn something from our fellow forum members. So…
1) What are your favorite bits? Make + model/series?
2) Do you like Anti-cam out style bits?
3) Where do you get your bits?
Currently my favorite bit is Bosch, I’ve been using them for a while but I wished they fit a little better and the steel was a bit harder. They do hold the screw well but it seems that the ribs lessen the contact area so they’re more prone to cam out at high torque. You can get these at Lowe’s, Amazon, eBay.
The Milwaukee 1st gen Shockwave bits are just awful, the fit isn’t very good, the steel is soft. Literally every single one I’ve handled has been bent out of the box. Just don’t get them, 2nd gen can be had at Home Depot.
Makita, good fit but nothing really stood out. I can’t remember where I got these.
Kobalt, this one I need to test more. I owned a bit for about a three days before i decided to return the quick release system the bits came with in favor of the Bosch quick release(which is a lot nicer). The bits felt really good, seemed to fit very well but I didn’t use them a lot because I was considering returning the set. They felt very dense. I’m not sure if they are impact rated.
I just loaded up on the Germany made bits Felo, Wiha and Wera from KC Tools.
When I’m choosing bits it’s the gold makita ones. Like you said, not outstanding, just good bits which is all I really want. I’ve lost some and broken off screw heads but never damaged a bit.
Maybe others like ribbed or diamond coated are better, but the makita bits work well enough and are cheap enough I don’t see a point in looking for different bits.
I’ve used plenty of other bit types when they’re available on site and nothing seemed to work any better.
I like Wera impaktor the most. Hilti is a close second. They don’t wear nearly as fast as the big three brands. Impaktor bits don’t cam out or round off easily.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I like Dewalt max fit bits. They come with a yellow magnetic sleeve for reducing wobble on your impacts. Very durable bits and they seat very nicely in screws. The only place I have ever found these are at Home Depot. I’ve used other dewalts, craftsman, shockwave gen 1, and other nameless brands and nothing lasts like these guys do. Never used any Irwin or Bosch but after I found these I kind of stopped looking.
Jimbo
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I used to use a plane Jane Bosch 1″ bits, no special impact rating or anything.. They had 25pks at Lowes if I remember. They held up surprisingly well, much better than all other brands I had used at the time. now I buy mostly Makita Gold usually just from home depot and they are great!
I am currently using the Dewalt max fit bits and so far I really like them I got them at Home Depot
With ph2 I prefer a great fitting bit rather then one that lasts ages but doesn’t quite fit right which a lot don’t ! For that reason I like the dewalt extreme ph2 50mm long ones they fit perfect [External image (images.tapatalk-cdn.com), not copied]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I’ve been using the Dewalt bits and want to try out the Makita ones.
chrisk wrote:
I’ve been using the Dewalt bits and want to try out the Makita ones.
The Makita bits always catch my eye but never picked them up.
Jimbo
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I picked up a Dewalt MaxFit and ordered Blue Point bits to add to the test group. I will post my results but it will take a looong time, so that’s why this is my first time mentioning it…these results will be like a year from now. I will post fit and comparison photos by early next week when all the bits are in. The only ones I think I’m missing is Apex, Zephyr and PB Swiss but the shipping rates are killing me. Maybe by the end of the sampling I will pick some of those up, seems like PB Swiss is going to have to come from Japan. Apex and Zephyr is a minimum $50 order and $10+ shipping. I believe I have Zephyr covered with the Blue Point bits but I’ll have to do some more research to confirm.
i’d like to add Makita gold bits to the group but I need a 3-4 inch bit and their 3.5″ bit is a double-sided phillips and I’ve never been a fan of double sided, they tend to wobble.
I haven’t noticed any wobble with the 3.5″ double ended makita bits.
i have always used bosch Titainium p2 bits 1″ they rarely snap off and last a while. Lowes stopped carrying them, but i loaded up on them from amazon.
http://www.amazon.com/Bosch-TDP2108-Titanium-Phillip-Screwdriver/dp/B00A43UERM
jeffmcmillan wrote:
I haven’t noticed any wobble with the 3.5″ double ended makita bits.
I haven’t used the Makita but the other double ended bits I’ve tried have wobbled…so maybe I’ll give it a go but are you using a 1/2″ chuck or a quick release?
PaulE wrote:
i have always used bosch Titainium p2 bits 1″ they rarely snap off and last a while. Lowes stopped carrying them, but i loaded up on them from amazon.
http://www.amazon.com/Bosch-TDP2108-Titanium-Phillip-Screwdriver/dp/B00A43UERM
To quote a movie that I don’t recall with that guy that is married to Kristen Bell “She may be ugly but at least she puts out”
u gotta try out the Makita bits bro they will surprise u.chrisk wrote:
I’ve been using the Dewalt bits and want to try out the Makita ones.
I just checked, and all the long bits I could find have about 1mm of play including Makita double ended. I noticed on the Makita bits, the drive head is ground right out of the hexagonal stock rather than turning it down to a smaller circle first, which probably explains the better grip over most double ended bits. I also just noticed my PH3 has a thicker torsion zone than the PH2, probably to give more impact to larger fasteners. They definitely put some engineering into those bits.
1mm of play isn’t bad, I’ll give her a shot. Might as well it’s only $4 for essentually two bits. Especially after I’ve invested soo much in the rest of the lineup I plan on testing.
The makita gold ones is pretty good. Haven’t been able to break/shatter the head, and they don’t wear down very quickly.
However, I’m able to warp/bend the “fins” on the Torx head with the impact driver. The philips head is just fine though.
The bosch diamond bits kinda fits/sticks better, and is also very good, if not even better. But have not tested them too long, too know if the ‘diamond’ layer will stick in the long run.
Just one more package and a trip to Home depot to go!
Each bit is a different make and/or model:
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
Were you going to test the new Milwaukee shockwave bits?
I think the new shockwave or more in line with the dewalt max fits, I’ll probably pick some up myself next time I make it to HD
Jimbo
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I really don’t want to even bother to be honest. That Shockwave is there just so I can compare the fit and physically show the difference between that and a quality bit. There are guys using these by choice and I want to show them why they could get better for their money. That may change as time goes on as I hear about whether the new Shockwaves are actually improved, it will be a long term test so there will be time. For the short term, I’ll show and go into detail of the fit (JIS and Phillips) and the various differences. Too many bits and not enough people(just me) to test them quickly but why not get good images and initial impressions? They all look the same with stock photos. It’s interesting to see the differences in the anti-cam out ribs, complete opposite way to accomplish the same idea between competing German manufactures.
Some of these German bits are machined ridiculously well for the price, AND some of them were cheaper than the Dewalt bit by over a dollar a piece! Though of the German bits were more expensive, that Harpoon bit with the anti-cam ribs were $6.50 a piece! Nice machining but I find it hard to believe that it’s nearly three times better than the Dewalt…I really don’t imagine these will hold up too well.
I just picked up the Makita bits going to try them tomorrow, been using shockwaves and max fit. In my experience max fit held up better. Curious about shockwave to but heard good things about Makita
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Bmack, that wera to the right of the Irwin looks crazy!! It looks like it should be a #1 or #0 bit instead of a #2 with how thin that shank is.
I’m curious to see how it holds up.. I would think you would loose a lot of torque to to torsional movement of that thin shank, maybe even premature snapping of the shank.. Humm. Interesting none the less!
I saw the makita gold bit kits for $12 yesterday at HD I think there usually around 14-15$ couple bucks off
Bigmikez wrote:
I saw the makita gold bit kits for $12 yesterday at HD I think there usually around 14-15$ couple bucks off
Seems like there’s always a sale on one or another of those. It’s like they’re trying to give out free crack and get everyone hooked.
Looking forward to your test results BMack!
I dont have extensive knowledge about bits but I like the DeWalt Max Fit bits. I have also used Bosch bits and I like the DeWalts better.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G870A using Tapatalk
I picked up the Makita and looked for the gen 2 Shockwave but they didn’t have it, so I lucked out. I had decided to buy one, get you the fit and just plop the guy in my impact driver, drive a couple and break it(presumably). VERY impressed with the Makita, glad you guys talked me into trying it…I didn’t know it was made in Japan!
I also got the Blue Point bits in yesterday. Early award and a COMPLETE shocker for best machinging goes to the bit from Taiwan. It’s machined nicer than my Snap-on Instinct screwdrivers! If the steel is as good, this may be the early favorite, was not expecting these to be even half as nice.
NERemodeling wrote:
Bmack, that wera to the right of the Irwin looks crazy!! It looks like it should be a #1 or #0 bit instead of a #2 with how thin that shank is.
I’m curious to see how it holds up.. I would think you would loose a lot of torque to to torsional movement of that thin shank, maybe even premature snapping of the shank.. Humm. Interesting none the less!
I don’t imagine it’s going to hold up too well. It’s easily the weirdest bit I have ever seen, it’s a little short for me and I don’t think it will last but I just had to see the thing. It’s supposed to be rated for use in “Sheet metal and metal” but so is the other similar colored Wera bit (851/4 Z)…no idea what the thinking of the shape or shaft really is but I imagine it’s going to snap on anything above 18 on my clutch…but stranger things have happened. I’m going to try to keep this one alive and test the ultimate ability to wear on the tip before I put some torque to it…at least that’s the plan.
BMack37 wrote:
I don’t imagine it’s going to hold up too well. It’s easily the weirdest bit I have ever seen, it’s a little short for me and I don’t think it will last but I just had to see the thing. It’s supposed to be rated for use in “Sheet metal and metal” but so is the other similar colored Wera bit (851/4 Z)…no idea what the thinking of the shape or shaft really is but I imagine it’s going to snap on anything above 18 on my clutch…but stranger things have happened. I’m going to try to keep this one alive and test the ultimate ability to wear on the tip before I put some torque to it…at least that’s the plan.
Looking forward to the results!
Why is it that your only into 4″ bits? I use a bit holder and 1″ bit 95% of the time. Only when I have a specific need will I reach for a 2, 4 or 6″ bit
NERemodeling wrote:
Looking forward to the results!
Why is it that your only into 4″ bits? I use a bit holder and 1″ bit 95% of the time. Only when I have a specific need will I reach for a 2, 4 or 6″ bit
It’s for my current job, doing electronics repair. I have to reach through to recessed screws. I want to be able to find one bit and/or line(or at least brand) that can do most of what I need(So I can buy at one place/time). 1″ bits are easy to find, everyone has those in every available option. So limiting myself to the longer bits gives me a starting point and I can go from there with my 1″ bits…so if I like the Wera bits I can try the Impaktor bit for my short bits(not available in longer lengths). Basically, it limited me to 11 bits instead of 30+ !!
Andrull wrote:
The makita gold ones is pretty good. Haven’t been able to break/shatter the head, and they don’t wear down very quickly.
However, I’m able to warp/bend the “fins” on the Torx head with the impact driver. The philips head is just fine though.
The bosch diamond bits kinda fits/sticks better, and is also very good, if not even better. But have not tested them too long, too know if the ‘diamond’ layer will stick in the long run.
I’ve noticed the same thing with the makita golds; the PH2 are very good but the Torx tips seem to twist into swirls a little too easily…
Dewalt flextorq and Bosch are what ive been using for the last year or so,Id like to try the new shockwave bits.
I have some Wera kits but not the newer impaktor styles.
I usually use Ridgid bits.
I didn’t even know Ridgid had bits.
I seem to have found something that should have been apparent but I didn’t consider in the fitment test…apparently phillips and JIS screws have a noticeable variance in how they’re cut into the screws. Also I found a few surprising things; I discovered the fitment issue with the Milwaukee Shockwave bits…they’re JIS(Japanese philips) not Phillips and they fit those JIS well. Another surprising thing, the Makita gold, the ONLY bit from Japan, is Phillips and not JIS. My preferred (and a bit I’ve recommended numerous times) Bosch bit is now far from my favorite bit.
I’m having trouble figuring out a way to come up with a way to measure fitment other than by feel. I found that I’m really good at blindly feeling out the better fit in screws. My first blind test was checking fitment in a phillips screw head and three came out to be what I considered the same…turns out they were the three Wera bits. Then I tried another good condition phillips screw and got sightly different results. What I can tell you is another surprising result, every single bit fits into one of the four screws I tested better than my Klein screwdriver fits in ANY of the screws. I wanted to also add the Klein into the fitment test because pretty much everyone has one…Snap on, Witte are also in the test. That is if I can find a way to measure the fitment, it’s really difficult when the tolerances are a fraction of a millimeter.
Yeah Ridgid bits are awesome!
nr777 wrote:
Yeah Ridgid bits are awesome!
Chinese I assume? That’s not a knock btw, Bosch, Dewalt and Irwin are also Chinese and are just fine. I just checked Home Depot online and it doesn’t seem like they have a lot of options. A couple of sets and two philips 1″ packs. Even Ryobi has more items…makes you wonder if either are mostly-unfound gems.
I use the Ridgid with the torque zone, they work hard and I love them!
No Wera love? The Impaktor bits are quite good.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
HiltiWpg wrote:
No Wera love? The Impaktor bits are quite good.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Most of the bits mentioned are from Lowe’s/HD. This is why I wanted to do this, almost all of these bits are Chinese, with Makita being the exception(Japan). The Germans, Czechs and I’m finding the Taiwanese are pretty damn good at making bits. The machining on the Chinese bits can be pretty good but when it comes to other tools, I’ve noticed the main issue with Chinese tools is the metal strength…which is damn important in bits. The thing is that we can’t just assume that all Chinese metal is poor quality, I’m more familiar with quality of carbon fibre and there is a HUGE discrepancy in Chinese carbon fibre from plant to plant…I can only assume this extends into other areas of material manufactering, including metal. I’ve found the Chinese do a wonderful job at making items for a specific pricepoint, expensive items can be made damn well. These Chinese bits are not cheap, they’re comparable to European pricing, so the metal may very well be good quality. I wish I did more impact driving so I could nail the strength thing down quickly but that kind of thing is left for the weekend for me and I don’t really have any wood projects right now.
BTW, not sure if I’ve mentioned it but I’ve been buying the German/Czech bits from KCTool for very reasonable prices. The shipping cost isn’t even that bad and it’s free shipping over $50. The Wera(Czech), Wiha(Germany) and Felo(Germany) bits are all quite nice.
Here are the high-ish resolution pics of the bits. I limited width to 1000 pixels so it was forum friendly.
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
This is a pretty poor picture of the anti-cam machinging so here’s further pictures:
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
Blue Point compared to Snap On screwdrivers:
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
Anti-cam out bit comparison:
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
Here are the other 10 bits:
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
[External image (i.imgur.com), not copied]
Which one is your favorite so far and which do you like the least?
Jimbo
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I really like the Blue Point(though it’s not rated for impact). Wiha, Felo and Wera(Haven’t really messed with the Harpoon) are all hard to pick from, it’s like comparing apples to other apples from the tree next to it.
My favorite that you can find in HD/Lowes is the one I almost didn’t buy; the Makita. My favorite was Bosch coming into this and it’s now far from the top, near the bottom. Dewalt seems pretty good but it doesn’t seem to fit as well as the European and the Makita bits.
Milwaukee is still my least favorite, though I’ve found it fits better in JIS screw heads which nearly solves the camming out/quick wear problem. One thing to note is that EVERY SINGLE ONE of these bits fits better in either phillips or JIS better than a Klein screwdriver fits in any of the same screws, was not expecting that.
I’ve come to prefer the smaller head bits, they seem to fit better into a wider range of screw heads. The Dewalt doesn’t seem to fit as well in smaller sized PH2 screws, it really prefers the deep PH2 screw heads.
One favorable detail with the makita is its gold color. It’s easy to find them between all to other bits and stuff. 😀 A small and unnecessary detail, but I like it.
So you quickly can find the quality ones, and not the el cheapo backup ones.
I miss som ridges at the tip though. My wera screwdrivers and one from bosch have them, and I feel like they stay just a tad better.
BMack37 wrote:
Kobalt, this one I need to test more.
Do a followup on Kobalt you probably will be surprised.
redmed wrote:
Do a followup on Kobalt you probably will be surprised.
They seemed very similar to the basic Bosch bit, though obviously not the same finish. I’ll probably buy some, need to go any try to find gen 2 Milwaukee bits also. I have tomorrow off so I might hit up HD and Lowe’s for these bits. Also need to look if Ryobi and Ridgid have any bits that will work for me.
Looked a bit closer on the milwaukee bits, and noticed all the “fins” on the torx head was gone, execpt one and a half. Haven’t used them more than perhaps 20 screws. Lol. Just as low quality as the free cheapo ones (Use and toss) you get when phurcasing new screws.
And they god damn cost me 5 dollar a piece (2 inch) (10 dollar for two-pack). 😛 Worst buy in history.
Are those the new Improved Milwaukee bits the sales rep was saying we’re made here?Andrull wrote:
Looked a bit closer on the milwaukee bits, and noticed all the “fins” on the torx head was gone, execpt one and a half. Haven’t used them more than perhaps 20 screws. Lol. Just as low quality as the free cheapo ones (Use and toss) you get when phurcasing new screws.
And they god damn cost me 5 dollar a piece (2 inch) (10 dollar for two-pack). 😛 Worst buy in history.
