Air impact recommendations

Archived from the Tools In Action forum (Power Tools). This thread is read-only.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

As you guys may or may not know I am going to tech school to be an auto mechanic and I have been accepted into the program. I need a good air impact (1/2 drive) for day in day out use. I am currently thinking about getting an ingersoll rand 2135 impact because my dad has one that he uses at his work (bus mechanic for the school) and it has been problem free until recently, considering he bought it when they came out with it, that isn’t too bad (he broke the anvil where the hammering mech hits). I was wondering if you guys had any other good recommendations. I will be getting 50% off of snap on, Mac, Matco, ect.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

The proto j150wp, has some of the most torque and power, and the cost is half of Snap-ons top impact, check out conductors review on the TIA homepage. I think that will be perfect for you.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

I saw that and considering that as an option.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

I saw that and considering that as an option.

It would also really turn some heads, as people never see Proto on air tools

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

I will probably wait and see what every one else thinks, plus I will order the m18 fuel impacts and drill first.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

I will probably wait and see what every one else thinks, plus I will order the m18 fuel impacts and drill first.

The fuel drill is really good, impresses me everyday, you will love it.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

How is the chuck on it? Do round drill bits slip when drilling steel or do you know? That is what I will be using mine for.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

How is the chuck on it? Do round drill bits slip when drilling steel or do you know? That is what I will be using mine for.

I had to drill out a bolt that i broke on my exhaust down pipe flange. I was using Milwaukee Black oxide drill bits, and started at i believe 5/32 and just worked my way up to 1/2in no problem. No slipping, the bits could have been sharper but the drill performed flawlessly. It has ratcheting chuck and imo it gripes pretty good, just as much as the jacobs chuck on the dewalt.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

Ok I was curious because I have a craftsman c3 drill that I use now and it will slip with an 1/8 inch bit unless you go as fast as possible. I bought the 29 piece set of dewalt pilot point bits and they work excellent on metal but for wood they will cause splintering on the exit hole but for rough stuff they work great. Give them a try and maybe do your own tool fight comparing them to the milwaukee bits.

DR99Member since Nov 2012

The ratcheting chuck makes all the difference which the Craftsmen c3 lacks.

Conductor562Member since Nov 2011

At 50% off you can actually get the Mac version of the Proto J150WP cheaper and it comes with the protective boot, plus you’d have a warranty service option of the truck or the Dewalt service center. AWP050 is the Mac model #. You can check it out on the Mac website. You’d be looking at $225 and much easier service than with an IR. It’s more gun than anything on the Snap-On truck.

Conductor562Member since Nov 2011

You probably know this Nick, but I know a lot of techs and I will offer you this advice:

Do not go and drop a ton of money on a truck brand box. Yes, they are nice, but you can get very good boxes for way less money. Montezuma, Extreme, and even HF. A box will get you in the hole quick and it’ll take forever to get out.

Take advantage of the 50% discount to buy your staple items. A set of Snap-On dual 80’s are highly recommended, Flank Drive+ combo wrenches, and sockets are some of the SO items worth looking at. It’s best to buy what you can while you’ve got the discount, because after it’s gone, the trucks will get in you picket quick.

Shop around. Even with the discount you may be able to get Proto, Blackhawk, wright, or Armstrong, sockets for less and they are just as good. You won’t be warrantying a lot of sockets, so it makes little sense to go the truck route IMO.

For pliers, I’d buy Channellock. They are WAY cheaper and will last forever.

Screwdrivers……with the discount I’d go Snap-On or Mac if you have the discount. Mac has a new driver out also being sold under the Proto label that are supposed to be awesome. I’m supposed to get a batch in the next week or. 2, so I’ll let you know. You don’t need a 100 piece set. Start with an 8 or 10 piece set and buy additionals as/if needed.

Also, the Proto Anti-Vibe hammers I reviewed at also sold as Mac. They are awesome.

I loath tool trucks, but with the student discount you can come out ahead. Like I said though, some things are worth getting off the truck, and some things aren’t. Shop around.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

I don’t even care for snap on tools as a whole. My uncle has some and they don’t seem any better than mine. He has blown the head out of his ratchet numerous times. I have a couple of napa ones. One of the old brand one of the new 100 tooth ones and I love it. I already have a craftsman box and will never get one off of a truck. One of my friends brothers has over 20 grand that he owes to the trucks. My dad absolutely hates truck brands, he uses either craftsman or the older napa hand tools where he works.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

I really like the Usa made williams era Kobalt and Williams stuff, also like the Sk wayne era, i think using vintage or older tools as your front line ratchet or wrench is bragging point to other people with there brand new fancy snap-on, Hell i use the b-52 that Conductor sent me as my go to 1/2in, and its over 50 years old!!!!! I cant wait till my grandfather gives me some of his stuff!! when i start finishing out my socket collection for my shop tool box, i usually always watch ebay, I also like the wera drivers that conductor did a review of. Channel lock for pliers, but i recommend getting a a pair of the Iwrin Quick grips, they are my most used tool, i recommend them to anybody, they are real quick to adjust, the handles are very comfortable, its not USA made, but i guarantee you its the closest thing to it, its really solid. 

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

I don’t use those type of pliers too much but if I ever need them I will try them. I do have some older s&k stuff and some proto wrenches and I like them.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

I don’t use those type of pliers too much but if I ever need them I will try them. I do have some older s&k stuff and some proto wrenches and I like them.

Lol not quick grips those are the clamps, I meant the groove locks…….lol

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

Oh I figured it was the pliers because you did a video on them.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

Oh I figured it was the pliers because you did a video on them.

Yeah i did, do they give you a list of what you have to have or you get what you want?

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

Not yet but it starts next year so it’s not like I don’t have time. I have the majority of the hand tools and air tools.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

What school is it?

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

It is a fairly local one here. It starts on the fall this year, I still thought it was 2013

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

It is a fairly local one here. It starts on the fall this year, I still thought it was 2013

Oh ok nice man. I have thought about Nashville diesel…its just so expensive

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

That would probably be 60 grand by the time you buy all of the tools, tuition, dorm/apartment and everything else.

firefighter4187Member since Mar 2013

NicholasShetley wrote:

That would probably be 60 grand by the time you buy all of the tools, tuition, dorm/apartment and everything else.

Yeah thats crazy, My auto teacher had a rep from there come talk to us, he of course fails to mention what it costs lol.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

Believe me he didn’t fail lol

Conductor562Member since Nov 2011

I’m a Proto nut (as if you didn’t already know). They are the best value in tools IMO. Truck brand quality for way less money. They aren’t always as flashy, but that isn’t my thing. If you ever want to get into Proto just let me know, Have about half the model numbers memorized, lol. Seriously, when it comes to Proto, Conductor knows his shit.

Here is all you need to know about tool trucks. They don’t run on hopes and dreams, they run on excess mark-up.

NicholasShetleyMember since Nov 2013

I do have some proto wrenches and a couple ratchets. They seem nice to me and I like them. I know that the army uses them quite a bit. When we went to the army surplus store (you have to work for the govt to buy stuff there.) there was a lot of proto stuff, mainly wrenches.

You are the influencer. Post it to 4.4 million followers.

Hit record. We’ll handle the rest.

Upload your review