New 3ah compact vs 5ah

Archived from the Tools In Action forum (Dewalt). This thread is read-only.

07SierraMember since Jul 2013

I know the 5ah could supply more runtime but with the new high end 21700 cells in the 3ah compact, do you think it could supply the same type of performance in the bigger tools like the impacts? Could it supply more amps compared to the the 5ah?

TrimmerMattMember since Oct 2017

5ah should still outperform the 3.  There are 2x the cells so they will see half the load.  21700 cells are better but not twice as good as 25r in the 5.0.  

07SierraMember since Jul 2013

Wonder how much better they are then the 2ah… Trying to decide between 1 3ah or getting 2 2ah

Cr8ondtMember since May 2016

I have multiple 2, 4 and 6ah, there is a significant noticeable difference when using the the 4/6 batteries in all my tools.   I believe the discharge rate of the 3 is better than the 2 but not quite the 4 or 6.  So based on that I’d go for the 5 vs the 3 all day long. the 3 is obviously a run time boost over the  2 but if my only choice were 2 2’s or 1 3 I’ed take the 2’s, charging 1 while using the other vs waiting for the 1 battery to charge.

BabysawMember since May 2018

If the service center deal if still live, that is your best battery deal. Turn in two ancient worthless batteries from a thrift etc for two 9/3 flexvolt, $199

JpgwoodworkingMember since Jan 2018

I’m not impressed with the 5ah batteries honestly. I have a bunch of 2 ah’s for drills, impacts, and small tools, and a bunch of the 6ah Flexvolts for saws, fan, vacuum, blower, etc. 

 

The Flexvolts are a significant increase in both power and run time for everything I use them in, but they are too heavy and bulky for the 6 1/2” trim saw and compact brushless recip. I use the 5 ah batteries in those tools, but it’s not uncommon to use 3 batteries in a day working by myself. The 2 ah’s and Flexvolts last close to a week in the tools I use them in. 

 

The 3 ah would be nice for the OMT, as it’s a battery hog but best kept light and compact. 

Framer joeMember since Nov 2016

Imo….the 5ah is the perfect battery in all 20v tools except nailers….I have dozens of all the batteries but 12ah….the 5ah are cheap on eBay also…

MordekyleMember since Dec 2016

2AH in finishing guns, They will run for days.

 

5 AH in Most other 20 V tools.

 

FV on the 20v saw. High increase in performance is worth way more than the small increase in weight.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

The.HandymanMember since Aug 2015

I love the new compact 21700 cell 3.0ah batteries in the nailers as it offers a wider more stable base to set the nailers on.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

ChrisKMember since Dec 2012

Mordekyle wrote:

6 hours ago, Mordekyle said:

2AH in finishing guns, They will run for days.

 

5 AH in Most other 20 V tools.

 

FV on the 20v saw. High increase in performance is worth way more than the small increase in weight.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

I run the 2.0 s in my Brad and finish guns but only 5.0s or flex volts in the framer. I love my 2.0 s. I might get a 3.0 at some point but…

BabysawMember since May 2018

The planer also runs noticeably stronger with flexvolt batteries. I rarely need more power than a 4ah can offer but it’s nice when you’re planing something super hard to have that extra oomph.

 

if I’ve got a grinding wheel on my drill, doing some rust cleanup etc a flexvolt battery is also nice. 

 

I’ve only got 6/2ah flex batteries, do the 9/3ah give more power, especially in the 575 saw?

Mattias BlomqvistMember since Apr 2015

Today was the first time I put a 9.0ah FV battery in my DCS367 recip saw and man what a difference in speed that boy got compared to a 5.0ah.

Skickat från min SGP511 via Tapatalk

Framer joeMember since Nov 2016

@Babysaw…I would only use 9ah or 12ah in the 575 and 577…huge difference in performance and runtime

JronmanMember since May 2016

I used a Flex in my OMT. Thats probably why it broke. Too much power. Using a 2/6 from full to empty in one session on the OMT creates a ton of heat. 

ToolBaneMember since Jan 2018

Jronman wrote:

1 hour ago, Jronman said:

I used a Flex in my OMT. Thats probably why it broke. Too much power. Using a 2/6 from full to empty in one session on the OMT creates a ton of heat. 

 

I’ve wondered at this proving to be a potential issue for some tools going forward. As they were almost certainly all developed and tested using what we presently think of as “standard” batteries that aren’t outputting as much current as these larger capacity batteries can, along with the higher work output they’ll now get is more heat production and accelerated wear. I’m interested in seeing how that plays out over time.

xrh07Member since Jun 2019

The 3.0 uses a Samsung 30T 35A cell.  5s1p = 35A max output.

The 5.0s use a Sanyo cell capable of ~20A.  5s2p = ~40A max output. 

 

You are the influencer. Post it to 4.4 million followers.

Hit record. We’ll handle the rest.

Upload your review