Saw blades- Sharpen or Replace???

Archived from the Tools In Action forum (Accessories). This thread is read-only.

Dano123Member since Feb 2016

Ok here is a question I have had for a while now.  I have a 10″ miter and 10″ table saw that I use frequently, but not daily. Does anyone sharpen their own blades, have them professionally sharpened or do you just pitch them when they get dull?  

hemdaleMember since Sep 2015

The true question is to know whether it’s interesting in terms of cost. Sharpening would be good if you can sharpen the blade at least twice but I don’t really know the average cost of a pro sharpening service

jeffmcmillanMember since Jun 2015

Depending on how you use the saw sharpening might not even be an option.  If you hit nails or other debris with any frequency while cutting, the teeth will chip or fall out before they dull and there’s no point to resharpening.  I’m not particularly good about this (don’t bother changing blades before demo work) so blades just get replaced.

Dano123Member since Feb 2016

I only cut clean lumber with these saws, but I use a lot of treated lumber. I haven’t priced professional sharpening yet, but we have a place near by that does it. My main thing is I would consider a more expensive blade if I could resharpen it a couple times for less than the cost of a new blade.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Turner85Member since Jun 2015

I recently purchased some faba branded blades and the teeth have about twice the carbide as dewalt blades etc so in my case I’ll be reshapening. As for the dewalt stock blade I chucked that

Dano123Member since Feb 2016

What do you use to sharpen them?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

Usually i use them as a quick frisbee… DONT CALL THE SAFETY WEINERS I KNOW!!!!! 

 

MikeInCtownMember since Mar 2016

hemdale nailed it for the most part. How much did the blades cost you? A good 10″ table saw blade can easily run $60-$100. Unless you hit something and broke a couple teeth off, I would send it/them out to be sharpened. (do it in multiples to save $$) Now if you bought the $20 blade to cut 2×4 pine for framing, then pitch it and get a new one.

 

I wouldn’t try to sharpen carbide blate tips myself. Let a company with the proper equipment sharpen the blades with the correct angles.

comp56Member since Sep 2014

the real question starts at the beginning how much do you spend on a blade? a typical 10″ finishing blade can run anywhere from $25 to right up to $225

Diablo is usually the best bang for your buck in around the $60-$90 mark….. getting it resharpened even 3 times will give you a total of $140 and that is like buying 4 blades @ $60-$90 so you do the math…..

What will you be cutting?

some times a blade is dull because of resin build up, this can be helped by soaking the blade in vinegar to break down the resin over night, remember resins harden like concrete and coats the carbides which dulls the cutter.

most pro sharpening shops will charge around $11- $15 per blade.

 for example most diablo blades can be sharpened up to 6 times

some other better brands even more, Forrest for example

If you know you are cutting new wood then spend the money on a good blade and get it sharpened a few times

if you know you will be cutting unknown wood all the time then get a cheap blade and replace

if you might cut both new wood and unknown wood then get a cheap blade and a good blade

a blade can still be used even if a tooth or two are missing…..

here is an example of a cheap blade versus a good blade notice the difference in the cutters….

 

Photo from the original forum

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

More than double the carbide than the Irwin

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

RickyMcGrathMember since Oct 2014

A little unknown secret. Home Depot will replace a Diablo blade for FREE. Most Diablo blades say “Lifetime Guarantee” on the blade and or package. If you keep your receipts and packaging, simple exchange.

tugnut1Member since Jan 2016

Dano123 wrote:

6 hours ago, Dano123 said:

Ok here is a question I have had for a while now.  I have a 10″ miter and 10″ table saw that I use frequently, but not daily. Does anyone sharpen their own blades, have them professionally sharpened or do you just pitch them when they get dull?  

 

It all comes down to cost.  I have always replaced my blades since I tend to spend on the lower end for my blades.  It doesn’t cost much to have them resharpened, but for me, it is just easier to replace my blades when they start cutting poorly.  

 

I tend to spend between $40 and $50 for my 10″ blades and around $65 for my 12″ blades.  They both last me about 2 years before I switch them out.  Now, if I were to buy a Forrester, it would cost around $100 and I would not want to throw that one out. I would get that one resharpened.

 

My uses are typically woodshop related with clean wood, so I never hit nails or foreign object.  Just plain old use, so that is why I can last so long on a blade.

DaveJr.Member since Nov 2015

I alway like to buy a new blade. Who doesn’t love to go to HD, Lowes, wherever, and actually have a reason to buy something not just “because we want it”. I usually buy only Diablo blades for my saws. (circular, table, miter, recip). The only blade Diablo doesn’t make are bandsaw blades.:D

ChrisKMember since Dec 2012

Dano123 wrote:

7 hours ago, Dano123 said:

Ok here is a question I have had for a while now.  I have a 10″ miter and 10″ table saw that I use frequently, but not daily. Does anyone sharpen their own blades, have them professionally sharpened or do you just pitch them when they get dull?  

Professionally sharpened. Ise use Festool blades as I’m set up for them and Forrest. Awesome blades from Forrest! They have a sharpening service too, make sure you keep your blade boxes.

 

https://www.forrestblades.com/#/home

Dano123Member since Feb 2016

Well I want to play Frisbee with Jimbo now, I heard as long as we wear gloves it’s perfectly safe.

As far as the blades go, I bought a $40 Dewalt combo pack with 2 10″ blades from Lowes last year. Considering I used the included blade from my Harbor Freight miter saw for several years including my patio construction I am sure the Dewalts will hold up better. The guy I “inherited” all of my old Craftsman tools from, who is 82, is the one telling me to have my blades sharpened. I feel like they are disposable at that price, but I would like to try better brands like Diablo, etc (not Festool Chris, I have purchased several vehicles for less than their miter saw costs!) blades when these go bad or I see a good deal.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Turner85Member since Jun 2015

Photo from the original forum

StercorariusMember since Dec 2015

JimboS1ice wrote:

Usually i use them as a quick frisbee… DONT CALL THE SAFETY WEINERS I KNOW!!!!! 

 

Lol, I rember the first time I saw my dad throw one like a frisbee to my uncle on the roof who was changing the blade. I don’t think I’ve ever felt more fear and respect at the same time at any other point in my life.

Turner85Member since Jun 2015

Testing one two, seems I can post again. I posted a picture lastnight of two blades showing the difference in carbide tooth size to back up my post stating I wouldn’t be bothered sharpening the dewalt but I would with the faba as it’s a lot better quality 

comp56Member since Sep 2014

Turner85 wrote:

14 minutes ago, Turner85 said:

Testing one two, seems I can post again. I posted a picture lastnight of two blades showing the difference in carbide tooth size to back up my post stating I wouldn’t be bothered sharpening the dewalt but I would with the faba as it’s a lot better quality 

I agree my local shop would say if it was worth it or not before hand too…..but then again I only have quality blades getting sharpened

 

StercorariusMember since Dec 2015

Do shops usually charge by the tooth count, by blade diameter, both, or a flat rate?

comp56Member since Sep 2014

Stercorarius wrote:

1 minute ago, Stercorarius said:

Do shops usually charge by the tooth count, by blade diameter, both, or a flat rate?

the shop I go to goes by dia. flat rate but it could be anything elsewhere

 

Turner85Member since Jun 2015

Mines by tooth. Think it’s about 30cents per tooth they charge 

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

That not a bad price compared to buying a whole new blade

hemdaleMember since Sep 2015

I’ve noticed that an excellent blade could last up to 5 times longer vs a cheap blade.

An excellent blade is not 5 times more expensive than a cheap blade.

Sharpening would also mean than you have a blade being sharpened while you are using the other. Than implies a larger number if blades to allow this rotation.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

hemdale wrote:

I’ve noticed that an excellent blade could last up to 5 times longer vs a cheap blade.

An excellent blade is not 5 times more expensive than a cheap blade.

Sharpening would also mean than you have a blade being sharpened while you are using the other. Than implies a larger number if blades to allow this rotation.

Very true and they make your saw last longer as well because it’s less stress on the motor than a dull blade

redmedMember since Dec 2014

Why not take a few bucks and a few minutes and give it a try?

 

KnarlyCarlMember since Jan 2016

Just got my set of hole saws and a larger single back…. These are Lenox hole saws, my favorite, and it cost $29 to sharpen the 6 piece kit plus the single 4-1/2″ holesaw. Originally $80 for the kit and $37 for the larger single one

 

[External image (farm2.staticflickr.com), not copied]

.

 

[External image (farm2.staticflickr.com), not copied]

 

–

The only possible problem is that when they sharpened them, they ground off the hook that Lenox comes with, i sure hope it doesn’t diminish the performance, but that really took me back, I think that’s one of the reasons they work so well, i’m going to be upset if they don’t work like new… i have a new set to use when these went in to get sharpened and I will find out if they really make a difference. Although another problem is the kerf that might be lessened because the teeth are worn on the sides, giving me less clearance between the holesaw and the hole i’m cutting. I don’t see any indication of adjustments to the teeth, although I’m sure the metal is too hard to bend them any further, and sharpening removes more material on the very tip, making that space even more narrow.

Basically every other tooth is bent outwards and the other teeth are bent inwards to create space for the incoming body of the holesaw as it enters the cut, on carbide blades, this is accomplished by the carbide teeth, they are wider than the blade. WIth these hole saws, cutting more material off the tips to sharpen each tooth brings the tooth down closer to the body of the holesaw, leaving less room for the body of the holesaw to turn in the wood, because of build up of saw dust causing friction and resistance… Well mabe my next set will be carbide tipped holesaws!

Here’s what they look like new, notice the hook on each tooth

[External image (www.buildersdepot.com), not copied]

 

 

KatoMember since Jan 2014

If they messed with the offset it won’t cut as well, and it won’t stay “sharp” for very long.

JimboS1iceMember since Sep 2015

I have the milwaukees another shot and they did pretty well, used 1 1/2″ and 3 1/2″ and they did well, just had bad luck with the one

Jimbo

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

tonylandinMember since Dec 2015

RickyMcGrath wrote:

A little unknown secret. Home Depot will replace a Diablo blade for FREE. Most Diablo blades say “Lifetime Guarantee” on the blade and or package. If you keep your receipts and packaging, simple exchange.

Could be worth buying another if you don’t have pkg or receipt and “trade” them out then you have two.

WigWagWorkshopMember since May 2015

Table saw blades no, but I will sharpen my bandsaw blades. 

 

-Steven

KnarlyCarlMember since Jan 2016

Took two blades to Ace hardware for them to sharpen, they did very nice job, for a grand total of @21.60 for both

 

 

…

pancingMember since Jul 2016

yeesh, ive never paid more than 50 bucks for a blade, ive always used industrial hitachi blades ( not the ones you get stock in lowe’s or menards) from amazon or special order from lowes.

You are the influencer. Post it to 4.4 million followers.

Hit record. We’ll handle the rest.

Upload your review